Explaining the Foundations of the Business-Oriented Approach to Research and Technology Organizations: A Critical Approach to the Privatization Policy of Public Research Institutions and Centers

Bandarian, Reza

doi:10.22034/jtd.2023.704492

Explaining the Foundations of the Business-Oriented Approach to Research and Technology Organizations: A Critical Approach to the Privatization Policy of Public Research Institutions and Centers

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Reza Bandarian

Business Develoment Department, Technology Management Division, Research Institute of Petroleum Industry

https://doi.org/10.22034/jtd.2023.704492

Abstract

Research and technology organizations are one of the organizations related to technology development activities that constitute the major part of public research institutions and centers in Iran. Given the spread of privatization to the field of research and technology in Iran and the inclusion of public research institutions and centers in the agenda of privatization, the purpose of this article is to critically review the privatization policy of research and technology organizations.
For this purpose, by examining the characteristics and historical evolution of research and technology organizations and explaining the business-oriented approach in these organizations, the challenges of privatization of research and technology organizations in Iran have been explained. Accordingly, regardless of whether the research and technology organizations are governmental or not, the business-oriented approach can be implemented in them, and privatization is not necessary to turn public research and technology organizations into an entrepreneurial and value-creating organization, and the idea that research and technology organizations can be driven towards financial autonomy (financial self- sufficiency) by forcing them to monetize from industry is a strategic mistake that has already been tried and tested in the world's leading countries and has not been successful. It is also a strategic mistake to consider the business-oriented approach to research and technology organizations as equivalent to forcing them to generate revenue. Another misconception in Iran is that if research and technology organizations are eliminated, technological startups or knowledge-based companies will be better and superior alternatives for them.

Keywords

Research and Technology Organizations

Privatization

Business Oriented Approach

Subjects

review the performance of research centers in technology development

Islamic Consultative Assembly; "Law on Support of Knowledge-Based Companies and Institutions and Commercialization of Innovations and Inventions", 2010(Persian).

Available at: https://www.rrk.ir/Laws/ShowLaw.aspx?Code=7907

Bandarian R.; Bandarian M.; "Strategic analysis of the status of Research and Technology Organizations of Iran", Journal of Industrial technology development, Vol. 9, Issue 17, 2011.(Persian).
Ghazi Nouri, S.; "Challenges and Concerns of Privatization of Research Centers", 2015. (Persian)

Available at: https://www.atf.gov.ir/fa/news

Fatemi, A.; "Considerations for the privatization of research centers", 2014. (Persian)

Available at: http://ayaronline.ir/1393/04/69276.html

Ziaei, M.; "Knowledge, Innovation and Knowledge-Based Development; the Role of Research and Technology Organizations", 1 sted. Tehran: Jihad Agricultural Engineering Research Institute Publications, 2009. (Persian)
Technopolis; Appendix A: RTOs and international engagement in science and innovation, 2005.

Available at: http://www.bis.gov.uk/assets/biscore/corporate/migratedd/publications/f/file30064.pdf

Thuriaux-Alemán, B.; Webster, P.; Eagar, R.; Ku, B.; Research & Technology Institutes Meeting the Challenges of the Post-Recession World, Arthur D. Little’s London office, 2010.
Rush, H.; Hobday, M.; Bessant, J.; Arnold, E.; "Strategies for best practice in research and technology institutes: an overview of a benchmarking exercise", R&D Management, Vol. 25, Issue 1, pp. 17-31, Jan 1995.
Arnold, E.; Clark, J.; Jávorka, Z.; Impacts of European RTOs. A Study of Social and Economic Impacts of Research and Technology Organisations, A Report to EARTO, Technopolis Group Ltd. 2010 Oct 20.
Coccia, M.; "New models for measuring the R&D performance and identifying the productivity of public research institutes", R&D Management, Vol. 34, Issue 3, pp. 267-280, Jun 2004.
Koch, G.; Leitner, KH; Bornemann, M.; Measuring and reporting intangible assets and results in a European Contract Research Organization. InJoint German-OECD Conference Benchmarking Industry-Science Relationships, 2000 Oct 16 (pp. 16-17).
Dastjerdi, R. DK; Jafarnejad, A.; "The strategic management model of technology development in research and technology organizations of oil industry: Case of mixed method", Journal Of Science and Technology Policy, Vol. 4, Issue 3, pp. 39-56, 2012. (Persian)
Martínez-Vela, C.; "Benchmarking research and technology organizations (RTOs): a comparative analysis", Work Paper Series, MIT Industrial Performance Center, MIT-IPC Working, Jun 2016:16-005.
Bandarian, R.; Bandarian, M.; "Effective Model of Technology Development in Research and Technology Organizations", Journal of industry & University, Vol. 5, Issue 17, pp. 27-38, 2013. (Persian)
Bandarian, R.; strategic research and technology management, 2nd. Tehran: Hooshmand Tadbir Publication; 2016. (Persian).
Suzana, A.; Maavak, M.; Yong, CC.; "The Challenges of Corporatization Policy for Government Research and Technology Organizations for Wealth Creation. Journal of Science", Technology and Innovation Policy, Vol. 1, Issue 2, pp. 1-21, 2015.
Thurner, TW; Zaichenko, S.; "Research and Technology Organizations (RTOs) in the primary sector: Providing innovation to Russia's mines and corn fields", European Journal of Innovation Management, Vol. 17, Issue 3, pp. 292-310, 2014.
Mc Dougall, J.; Kramers, J.; Ladd, J.; "Strategic Management Tools for Leading RTOs in Transformation", Proceedings for International Seminar on Best Practices for Collaboration between RTOs and SMEs, 1996.
Nath, P.; Mrinalini, N.; "Measuring R&D Effectiveness: organizational Benchmarking for non-corporate R&D organizations", In Proceedings for International Seminar on Best Practices for Collaboration between RTOS and SMEs. International Seminar on Best Practices for Collaboration between Research and Technology Organizations and Small and Medium-Sizes Enterprises, WAITRO, Poland,
Bozeman, B.; Rogers, J.; "Strategic management of government-sponsored R&D portfolios", Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 19(3), 413-442, 2001.
Pieris, N. M.; Technological contribution to facilitate the development of SMEs: The success of ITI (CISIR), Sri Lanka: International Seminar on Best Practices for Collaboration between RTOs and SMEs. World Association of Industrial and Technological Research Organisations (WAITRO), 2000.
Narimani, M.; Heidari, H.; Shoja Moradi, A.; "Presenting a Policy Model to Improve the Licensing Capacity of Engineering Services in Iran", Public Policy Journal, Vol. 7, Issue 4, pp. 29-47, 2022. (Persian)
Khayyatian, MS; Salami, SR; "Representation of the Barriers to Optimal Use of Private Research Institutes", Journal of Management Improvement, 6, Issue 4, pp. 57-75, 2013. (Persian)